‘Defense by ChatGPT’

Judges are now sanctioning attorneys who use AI to draft legal filings, and the Department of Justice is actively using AI detection…

By Vane November 17, 2026 1 min read
‘Defense by ChatGPT’

Judges are now sanctioning attorneys who use AI to draft legal filings, and the Department of Justice is actively using AI detection tools to catch them. Lawyers for the government have accused opposing counsel of submitting “AI slop” in a high-profile voter fraud case.

Legal teams working for the Department of Justice are deploying the AI writing detection service Pangram to argue that opposing attorneys are relying on artificial intelligence to compose their legal arguments. In one specific instance, government lawyers told the court that the defence was engaging in “defense by ChatGPT.” They claimed the opposing side was generating “AI slop” filings.

These details come from court filings reviewed by 404 Media. Over the past few years, we have documented numerous instances where lawyers were caught by judges after citing hallucinated cases that do not exist. The filings from this recent court case show that attorneys, including those working for the government, are attempting to catch each other using AI. They are then citing their opponents’ AI use in their arguments presented to the court.

“This case has turned into defense by ChatGPT,” government attorneys wrote in the case, which centers around a high-profile voter fraud case. “Motions practice in this case is the equivalent of writing responses to documents generated by a robot that is attempting to practice law. It cannot be that the local rules envisioned that it was acceptable for defense to use what the kids would call ‘AI slop’ to create multiple frivolous motions that waste judicial resources and fail to serve the cause of justice.”

What it means

The shift is moving from judges punishing individual users to prosecutors weaponising detection tools against opposing counsel. The practical result is a new layer of scrutiny where government lawyers are not just arguing the law, but arguing the origin of the documents submitted. This increases the risk of sanctions for defence teams caught relying on automated drafting tools.

Scroll to Top