ICML Author Removal [D]

ICML author removal is a contentious issue, especially for early-career researchers like the person seeking advice. The situation described highlights several key points:

– **Policy Ambiguity**: There appears to be ambiguity in how ICML handles authorship changes after initial submissions and reviews. This uncertainty can lead to disputes over contributions and approval processes.

– **Conflict of Interest**: Industry coauthors, while contributing, may have conflicting interests with their employer, complicating the process of getting explicit permission for their inclusion.

– **Paper Acceptance Timing**: The delay in addressing authorship issues likely exacerbated tensions between the student and the PC. By accepting the paper without resolving these issues, ICML may be setting a precedent that favors rapid acceptance over fair and transparent processes.

The most likely outcome is that the paper will proceed to publication as accepted with the current list of authors. However, this decision could set a negative precedent for future submissions and reviewer/PC practices. For the individual in question, withdrawing their submission might be seen as the only way to maintain integrity and fairness.

Stay ahead of AI. Get the most important stories delivered to your inbox — no spam, no noise.

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

Email Name

Name *

First

Last

Email *

Submit